Holly's Inbox All articles
Honest Finds

Four Pots, One Frosty Windowsill and an Honest Ledger: My Winter Growing Experiment

Holly's Inbox
Four Pots, One Frosty Windowsill and an Honest Ledger: My Winter Growing Experiment

Photo: Andy / Andrew Fogg from near Cambridge, UK, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Every November the garden centre does something to my brain. The bulbs come out in those crates, the labels promise spring, and for about forty minutes I believe I am a person with a greenhouse and a potting bench and possibly a wicker trug.

I am not. I have a 62cm windowsill above a radiator, a north-east facing sash window that hasn't been touched since the flat was built, and a supermarket shop I already wince at. So this winter I set a hard rule: £9, nothing that can't be eaten, and no buying anything with the word 'kit' on it.

Consider this the ledger.

The planting list, and what it actually cost

That's £9.30, and I'm rounding it to £9 because the garlic was already mine and I refuse to be precious about it. No fancy compost, no grow light, no self-watering gadget. Two old terracotta pots, one plastic tray from a takeaway, and a jug.

The cost-per-sprig maths nobody wants to do

This is where windowsill growing usually falls apart. For the first fortnight you have a pot of soil and a lot of hope, and every leaf is technically worth about £4.

By week three I had snipped maybe fifteen garlic greens. That's 60p a sprig if you're being brutal — comfortably worse than buying a bunch. But by week six I was cutting two or three a day off the same pot, and the maths flipped hard. The last fortnight worked out at something like 4p a sprig.

Compare that to the sad cellophane bag of cut parsley that costs about 80p and turns to slime by Thursday. Over a winter, the £9 is genuinely earned back. It just takes six weeks of looking at bare compost first, and most of us quit in week two.

The two that properly earned their place

Garlic greens. The best thing I grew all winter and the cheapest. You push cloves into soil, pointy end up, water them, and within ten days you've got bright green shoots. Snip the tops and they come again. The flavour sits somewhere between a spring onion and a gentle garlic, and they are unreasonably good stirred through eggs on a Saturday morning, or over a bowl of the soup I make in industrial quantities every January.

Flat-leaf parsley. The trick, which I got from a Gardeners' World episode I half-watched while folding washing, is to split the supermarket pot into three smaller ones immediately and give it fresh compost with a bit of grit. Mine sat through a cold snap and kept going. Not glamorous, no Instagram moment, but I haven't bought a herb bag since October.

The basil that behaved like a diva

The basil died in eleven days and I'd like to formally blame it.

It wanted full sun in a room that gets about three hours of weak November light. It hated the radiator below the sill. It sulked when I watered it, then sulked harder when I didn't. The leaves blackened from the bottom up, which is basil for 'I am not doing this anymore'. I killed it with attention, frankly.

The hyacinth was my own fault in a different way. I filled the jar too high, the bulb sat in water like it was having a bath, and it rotted quietly and then loudly. For a week my kitchen smelled like a swimming pool that had given up.

So: two wins, one diva, one £3 lesson. That feels about right for a first attempt.

Would I bother again in 2026?

Yes, but differently, and with a shorter list.

Next winter I'll do garlic again without a second thought — three pots this time, staggered a fortnight apart so I'm not snipping a forest in one week and nothing the next. I'll buy two parsley pots and split them straight away. I'll skip the prepared hyacinth entirely and put that £3 towards a cheap tray that actually catches water instead of dribbling it down the wall.

And I won't buy a grow light. I know myself, and I know a £6 gadget is how a £9 experiment becomes a £40 hobby I abandon in February.

The honest version of small-space growing is this: it isn't cheaper than the supermarket, it isn't fast, and half of it dies. But there's something quietly good about making a sandwich in the middle of a grim, dark week and cutting the green stuff from two feet away.

Right, I'm off to snip something. Holly x

All Articles

Related Articles

Behind the Shampoo: The 31-Day Toiletries Ban That Found £84 I'd Already Spent

Behind the Shampoo: The 31-Day Toiletries Ban That Found £84 I'd Already Spent

The 19-Link Christmas Folder That Called Out My Magpie Brain

The 19-Link Christmas Folder That Called Out My Magpie Brain

The Supermarket Face Mask That Quietly Outperformed My £40 Standby in 2026

The Supermarket Face Mask That Quietly Outperformed My £40 Standby in 2026